RSS Feed This entry was posted on Wednesday, July 1st, 2009 at 8:15 am and is filed under FYI. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
 |
- At Other Sites
- Beam Me Up
- Book Review
- Breaking News
- CBO
- Discussion
- From the Trenches
- FYI
- Ground Control to Sen. Democrats
- Health Alert
- 2008 Election
- African AIDS
- Babies
- Bad Studies
- Book Reviews
- Bush Health Plan
- Diabetics
- Drugs
- Health Care Access
- Health Care Costs
- Health Reform
- HSAs
- International
- Malpractice
- Media Advisory
- Medicaid
- Medical Economics
- Medical Tourism
- Mental Health
- Minimum Wage
- Portability
- Racial Disparities
- RAND Studies
- Safety
- Scary Forecasts
- SCHIP
- Seniors/Medicare
- Socialized Medicine
- Supply Side
- Telemedicine
- Transparency
- Uninsured
- Vet Care
- Vision Thing
- Workers Comp
- Hits & Misses
- Holiday
- In Memoriam
- In the News
- Interesting Videos
- Memorial Day
- New Videos
- NHS Update
- Notable and Quotable
- Obesity Update
- On Capitol Hill
- Personal Testimony
- Petition
- Plans
- Policy Update
- Question of the Week
- Quote of the Day
- Season's Greetings
- Song of the Season
- The People Speak Out
- Updates
Categories
Contributors
- Ron Bachman
- Michael Bond
- John Goodman
- Linda Gorman
- Robert Graboyes
- John R. Graham
- Devon Herrick
- Regina Herzlinger
- Roy Ramthun
- Greg Scandlen
Recent Posts
- Quote of the Day
- The Obesity Paradox, MIT Scientists Beaming, and New York’s Life Expectancy Gap
- But Senator Baucus, Did the “Experts” Read the Bill?
- We-Have-to-Pass-It-to-See-What’s-In-It Fact of the Day
- Is the Federal Government Broke?
- Why Is the Economy Not Recovering?
- Federal Government to Pay Medical Bills for Fortune 500, Nebraska Gov. Urges Educators to Support Repeal of ObamaCare, and Unemployment Insurance
- Unintended Consequences of the Medicare Drug Benefit
- Mr. Language
- An Interesting Post
Blogroll
Jul 1, 2009
This is from Ezra Klein:
Paul Starr has an important column today on the dangers of a badly designed public plan. The issue essentially comes down to adverse selection. If the public plan becomes a dumping ground for the sick and the old, it will be too costly for the young and the healthy. Rates will go up, and conservatives will point to the plans as costing X percent more than private insurance, thus proving the inefficiency of the government.
Hat tip to Marginal Revolution.
4 Responses to “Another View: The Private Plans Might Drive the Public Plan Out of Business”
RSS
Twitter
YouTube
LinkedIn
Facebook
Flickr
Helium
July 1st, 2009 at 10:30 am
Interesting point. However, I think the adverse selection could be offset by lower fees paid to providers.
July 1st, 2009 at 10:36 am
Agree with Ken. I’ll bet on the government plan.
July 1st, 2009 at 11:12 am
I don’t think lower provider fees would be enough to offset adverse selection. However I would be surprised if private insurers weren’t forced into whatever risk adjustment scheme is used for the public option. I don’t think employers will get out of ERISA or HIPAA regulations by virtue of purchasing through an exchange.
July 1st, 2009 at 2:54 pm
I accept Mr. Starr’s argument, but not his conclusion. We can see by the behavior of the private insurers, which are strongly resisting the government plan, that they do not think that they can dump expensive patients.
Mr. Starr does not believe that the government plan is a “Trojan Horse”. Well, that’s his right. However, the lemon dropping that he describes would be manna from heaven for the single-payer extremists who want government monopoly. It would allow them to increase taxes on the private carriers to compensate, putting them into a death spiral and out of business.